Law as Standing

Avihay Dorfman, Alon Harel, John Gardner, Leslie Green, Brian Leiter
July 29, 2020

This article addresses a basic question of general jurisprudence, namely, what difference law makes in moral space. It argues that the difference at issue does not necessarily come to telling us what morality (or justice) might dictate but rather to establishing a way of attributing decisions to all of us and not to any one of us in particular. This also means that law’s distinctive moral virtue is not justice but legitimacy. What renders this possible is the emergence of public officials whose value lies in being public officials. In that, the article defends the standing conception of law, according to which law’s most basic moral contribution is that of establishing an entity whose normative pronouncements could count as made in the name of (or even by) the polity.

Full Citation

Avihay Dorfman, Alon Harel, John Gardner, Leslie Green, Brian Leiter. “Law as Standing.” In 4 Oxford Studies In The Philosophy Of Law, Page 93 (July 29, 2020).